Improving Ensemble Culture in the non-major University Band Model: A literature review connecting student belongingness and music director best practices

Patty Saunders
UNC Greensboro

Elm Fork I
Friday, March 28th
10:30 am

Clinic Synopsis

This presentation discusses best practices of the university wind band conductor considering the correlation between student belongingness and the cultivation of positive ensemble culture within the non-major University Band through a comprehensive literature review. As schools of music continue to recognize the importance of a more diverse, equitable, and inclusive student population, research is needed to highlight best practices that encourage an increase in belongingness to uplift positive culture. The non-major, University Band has additional considerations with the variety of majors represented and gamut of musical skill, practice routine, and commitment to the study of music versus music for enjoyment. Belongingness is defined as “the extent a student feels included, accepted, valued, and supported” (Renn, 2022). Connections between Self-Determination Theory (SDT), belongingness, ensemble culture, and best practices for the music educator will be discussed. SDT assumes that individuals inherently seek learning and growth but require support (Ryan & Deci, 2017) that determines both volition, performance goals, and initiative (Howard et. al. 2021). Utilizing the Sense of Belonging Scale (SoBS) descriptors created by Hoffman (2002), areas of belongingness will be defined and applied to best practices across four key areas: perceived classroom comfort, perceived faculty support, perceived peer support, and perceived isolation. Conclusions will include discussion and application regarding best practices that contribute to attendance, practice routines, repertoire selection, rehearsal productivity, musical growth, rehearsal technique, logistics, and membership retention considering the non-major University Band model. Ethnographic observations will also be included as the presenter is a first-year teacher of record of a mostly non-major University Band and is working toward positive ensemble culture through belongingness and best practices.

Biography

Patty Saunders is pursuing a Doctor of Musical Arts in instrumental conducting at the University of North Carolina at Greensboro (UNCG) where she studies with Jonathan Caldwell. At UNCG, she conducts the Concert Band, instructs undergraduate conducting, and assists with all other aspects of the UNCG Bands.

Prior to coming to UNCG, Patty completed a master’s degree in instrumental conducting from the University of Cincinnati College - Conservatory of Music (CCM) with Kevin Holzman where she worked with the Wind Symphony, Wind Ensemble, Chamber Winds, and Brass Choir as a graduate assistant. She holds undergraduate degrees in music and psychology from the University of Kentucky where she studied saxophone with Lisa Osland and in biochemistry from Virginia Tech. She spent many years serving non-profit music organizations as well as collaborating with civic and professional groups in her community. Patty is passionate about connecting with audiences, musicians, and students through rehearsal technique, repertoire selection, and performance excellence. Known as an educator eager to think outside of the box, she strives to broaden accessibility, emphasize collaboration, and increase representation within the wind band field.

Patty is a member of Phi Beta Kappa, the College Band Directors National Association, and the American Bandmasters Association. She strives to learn a new word every day, loves hiking with her family and dog, Ginger, and takes her coffee black, with no room for cream or sugar.